Gass
Member
Hello and Welcome to the Forums in your first post 
I'll try them one by one to my logic in anything I can offer you.
Though if having Adguard installed their proficient in some degree to an application for privacy and of understanding the basics here, as well to their online privacy needs.
Your probably right about TOR (as I've not gone there), but I've read it's to best leave it as a default setup and/or not touching it's installed default settings after the install, being as generic as all the other users of it then - possibly the "TOR Browser" here as well, as I've said I've not gone there - only reading of it. So it's not exactly clear to me.
On the other hand a VPN (in modern today VPN's), most all have client side installations and don't require a system's network approach to changing any settings or using them in that way.
These VPN clients (software client installs on your system), require very little tweaking in settings and it's a set and forget other than changing where you want to appear your connecting from the servers it's to offer.
The better VPN providers will tell you what to consider/change to be set in them for better security of their use on your computer, or mobile device.
VPNs really don't slow your network connects down (I've a slow Mobile Data hotspot connection to PC)-(1 bar showing most all the time) and except for streaming this or that, it's about the same either way / using a VPN or not. I can and do live with it as it's the cheapest way to get online for me.
By the way, I use this VPN mostly for it's encryption of my whole PC's network and to hiding my IP, then again, I don't find a need to go to another continent 3,000 miles away either to connect to a node/server there for my internet usage.
As for ones connection speed with a VPN, that was covered above, unless you've meant of the users own ability to technology adaption - being slow? Depends on howa hungry they are and where they want to be with their online privacy, as much as they can with any methods, to their understanding it and to muster in a viable benefit to themselves, laymen's or not.
Please note that DNSCrypt is not a replacement for a VPN, as it only authenticates DNS traffic, and doesn't prevent third-party DNS resolvers from logging your activity.
By design, the TLS protocol, as used in HTTPS and HTTP/2, leaks websites host names in plain text, so DNSCrypt is not enough to hide this information.]
As this was quoted from their site https://dnscrypt.org/
Although they are fundamentally different, VPNs and proxies have a single thing in common - they both allow you to appear as if you are connecting to the internet from another location, then I'm sure if not for that single shared appearance of a connection from another location/masking your IP. It's like comparing apples to oranges otherwise for ones own network online privacy going through an encryption tunnel as only a VPN is to offer..
What I understand in the difference of proxy and a VPN - is a proxy is only working on a web browser based functions and a VPN is a system wide effect to your network of anything on your system connecting to the internet, every single application on your computer from your web browser to your online games to even Windows Update running in the background - everything.
This entire VPN process is all passed through a heavily encrypted tunnel between your computer and the remote network. This makes a VPN connection the most ideal solution for any sort of high-stakes network use where privacy or security is of your concerns.
Bottom line:
A VPN provides security by encrypting your network connections from your PC/device to the VPN Node/server.
Generally a Proxy doesn't provide encryption, therefore unauthorized 3rd parties can easily intercept your communication and access your private data, such as usernames/passwords, websites you visit and emails. I feel this is the case in using DNSCrypt as well, (as it has stated in it's own words), "DNSCrypt is not a replacement for a VPN, as it only authenticates DNS traffic, and doesn't prevent third-party DNS resolvers from logging your activity".
VPN can offer the feature to send DNS requests to it's own DNS server, then all DNS requests are sent through the encrypted VPN tunnel direct to your VPN provider’s DNS servers.
Though, most VPN providers run their own dedicated DNS servers in order to perform this DNS translation task themselves, but some make use of public DNS services such as Google DNS instead, and then don't offer their subscribers use of their own self run private DNS resolvers.
So choosing a VPN and understanding these differences would be advised...
We were all here/there once - green as grass, and to digest ones reading into an understanding, and then in gaining the practical ability to it's execution - is at ones own pace. I'm personally not where I'd like to be, but I'm not at the bottom step of technologies growing ladder, and in my own knowledge to online privacy - so I hope you'll agree.
Thanks, and welcome aboard...
EDITED:
Gass
I'll try them one by one to my logic in anything I can offer you.
Oh I do and it's the driving force to posting topics for their knowledge and a medium for discussions, seeing news and alerts, to an basic understanding it's all tied together in a way - for their benefit to comprehend such issues exists with their own on-line use to their privacy.@Gass Although I agree with your post at large, it's the solution that bothers me.
Consider an average user, a layman, I don't think you can expect them to know the intricacies of softwares like TOR and VPN.
How to setup the system and then configure it in a way, that it doesn't hamper your overall web browsing experience.
Though if having Adguard installed their proficient in some degree to an application for privacy and of understanding the basics here, as well to their online privacy needs.
Your probably right about TOR (as I've not gone there), but I've read it's to best leave it as a default setup and/or not touching it's installed default settings after the install, being as generic as all the other users of it then - possibly the "TOR Browser" here as well, as I've said I've not gone there - only reading of it. So it's not exactly clear to me.
On the other hand a VPN (in modern today VPN's), most all have client side installations and don't require a system's network approach to changing any settings or using them in that way.
These VPN clients (software client installs on your system), require very little tweaking in settings and it's a set and forget other than changing where you want to appear your connecting from the servers it's to offer.
The better VPN providers will tell you what to consider/change to be set in them for better security of their use on your computer, or mobile device.
VPNs really don't slow your network connects down (I've a slow Mobile Data hotspot connection to PC)-(1 bar showing most all the time) and except for streaming this or that, it's about the same either way / using a VPN or not. I can and do live with it as it's the cheapest way to get online for me.
By the way, I use this VPN mostly for it's encryption of my whole PC's network and to hiding my IP, then again, I don't find a need to go to another continent 3,000 miles away either to connect to a node/server there for my internet usage.
Only of TOR I'd expect it to mess with your speed because of the way it works, would do as well in this other area (javascript) and possibly any kind of Browser Extensions (Privacy Badger, DoNotTrackMe, NoScript, ScriptSafe, etc...) that have the ability to mess with a sites javascript delivery.The major block in adopting the technologies you mentioned is that they are slow. or involve process like not having javascript enabled at some places.
To a layman that's too much to work with. He would have to constantly work around problems, which IMO will only frustrate him to a point that he will most likely return to his earlier setup despite the privacy risk.
As for ones connection speed with a VPN, that was covered above, unless you've meant of the users own ability to technology adaption - being slow? Depends on howa hungry they are and where they want to be with their online privacy, as much as they can with any methods, to their understanding it and to muster in a viable benefit to themselves, laymen's or not.
Right above in my post #32 [Of Note:Although not the simplest of method but an easy one would be to encrypt your dns using something like dnscrypt proxy. That does away with all the things I mentioned in the para above. What's more it's a one time setup and forget thing. For a layman, that would be the best of the lot. And it's free.
Please note that DNSCrypt is not a replacement for a VPN, as it only authenticates DNS traffic, and doesn't prevent third-party DNS resolvers from logging your activity.
By design, the TLS protocol, as used in HTTPS and HTTP/2, leaks websites host names in plain text, so DNSCrypt is not enough to hide this information.]
As this was quoted from their site https://dnscrypt.org/
Although they are fundamentally different, VPNs and proxies have a single thing in common - they both allow you to appear as if you are connecting to the internet from another location, then I'm sure if not for that single shared appearance of a connection from another location/masking your IP. It's like comparing apples to oranges otherwise for ones own network online privacy going through an encryption tunnel as only a VPN is to offer..
What I understand in the difference of proxy and a VPN - is a proxy is only working on a web browser based functions and a VPN is a system wide effect to your network of anything on your system connecting to the internet, every single application on your computer from your web browser to your online games to even Windows Update running in the background - everything.
This entire VPN process is all passed through a heavily encrypted tunnel between your computer and the remote network. This makes a VPN connection the most ideal solution for any sort of high-stakes network use where privacy or security is of your concerns.
Bottom line:
A VPN provides security by encrypting your network connections from your PC/device to the VPN Node/server.
Generally a Proxy doesn't provide encryption, therefore unauthorized 3rd parties can easily intercept your communication and access your private data, such as usernames/passwords, websites you visit and emails. I feel this is the case in using DNSCrypt as well, (as it has stated in it's own words), "DNSCrypt is not a replacement for a VPN, as it only authenticates DNS traffic, and doesn't prevent third-party DNS resolvers from logging your activity".
VPN can offer the feature to send DNS requests to it's own DNS server, then all DNS requests are sent through the encrypted VPN tunnel direct to your VPN provider’s DNS servers.
Though, most VPN providers run their own dedicated DNS servers in order to perform this DNS translation task themselves, but some make use of public DNS services such as Google DNS instead, and then don't offer their subscribers use of their own self run private DNS resolvers.
So choosing a VPN and understanding these differences would be advised...
I like your reasoning and logic, to spell it out and that's what this THREAD IS FOR - Technical inexperienced, as well as advanced users in any degree to convey any helpful understanding and knowledge - that's factual based.[What do you think?
We were all here/there once - green as grass, and to digest ones reading into an understanding, and then in gaining the practical ability to it's execution - is at ones own pace. I'm personally not where I'd like to be, but I'm not at the bottom step of technologies growing ladder, and in my own knowledge to online privacy - so I hope you'll agree.
Thanks, and welcome aboard...
EDITED:
Gass
Last edited: